Exclusive | Reality star Johnny Bananas says he feared Lindsay Hubbard’s child was his, Hubbard says she never slept with him

Is this Banana being straight?

Reality star Johnny Bananas said on a podcast this week that he was afraid that he was the father of “Summer House” star Lindsay Hubbard’s baby.

But Hubbard says he’s… well, bananas, telling us, “I’ve never hooked up with him!”

A couple of years ago we reported that reality star Hubbard spent what should have been her wedding day on a first date with Bananas, who has appeared on MTV’s “The Real World,” and well as “The Challenge” and “House of Villains.”  

The “Summer House” star — who was supposed to be marrying co-star Carl Radke in November 2023, but she wound up going out for dinner wits Bananas instead.

In July she announced she was expecting with boyfriend Turner Kufe.

This week Bananas was on the “Hollywood Raw” podcast and told hosts Adam Glyn and Dax Holt, “The timeline of when the [date]  took place… made it real scary for me when a few months later it’s like, yeah, ‘Lindsay Hubbard is pregnant.’”

He added, “I’d like really go back and count the days, ‘Cause the timeline really could have like, ⁓ man.  I was. I was like, ‘Damn it.’”

But when we asked Hubbard about his claims, she said, “Is this guy for real?!! I’ve never hooked up with him!”

She added, “I went to a group brunch with him and one dinner with him last November. During the brunch, he asked me to go on a walk around the block. I was confused why but was like, ‘Uhh okay..’ Then I saw there were paparazzi pictures. He clearly called them and set me up.”

She said, “He’s trying to stay relevant and it’s sad he’s using me to do so.”

Hubbard gave birth to her daughter in December 2024 — even if she did sleep with Bananas she would have had to have been pregnant for 13 months.

We’d say everyone is in the clear.